The state of email encryption
S/MIME: A Central Approach
S/MIME [4], the second known mail encryption method, basically encrypts and signs in a way comparable to PGP but takes a more centralized approach to key generation and management. S/MIME certificates are issued, monitored, and declared invalid if necessary by a central certification authority. S/MIME is therefore suitable for structured use in a very controlled environment, for example, in public authorities or large companies. It is not surprising that classic business mail clients such as Outlook have always supported S/MIME natively.
On the other hand, S/MIME is less practical for private use, because there is initially no sensible centrally organized certification authority. Many years ago, there was an attempt by savings banks to issue S/MIME certificates to the masses via the S-Trust project, but this initiative did not catch on. The most practicable approach to date appears to be the Volksverschl¸sselung (People Encryption) project [5], which is run by the Fraunhofer Institute [6], which is worthy of recommendation but has not achieved widespread acceptance.
Unencrypted Metadata
If an email is encrypted using PGP or S/MIME, the encryption affects the entire body of the email, including the message text and any file attachments. The metadata of the mail header (i.e., information such as sender, recipient, message ID, and date) remains readable. The subject of an email is also classically part of the non-encrypted header data of an email. If desired, modern PGP implementations can also hide the subject in the encrypted body of the message so that it only becomes readable after decryption.
Encrypting in the Mail Client
If a mail program like Thunderbird encounters an encrypted message, it first identifies the key IDs used to encrypt the message and then checks whether there is a secret key for decrypting it in the internal keyring. If so, the program prompts the user to unlock their own key by entering a password. The mail can then be read normally and without any problems and, if required, displayed in the inbox together with the subject.
It makes sense for the mail program to keep the decrypted key in memory for a longer period of time, so that it can be used for hours without entering a password. The user can thus conveniently and transparently read and edit countless encrypted messages without even noticing that the messages are currently being decrypted in the background. It is only after a longer period of inactivity or after restarting the mail program that the user has to enter the key password again. This approach ensures maximum usability but theoretically also harbors the risk that an attacker could read the unsecured key from RAM.
To send an email, on the other hand, the generally known and password-free public key of the recipient is used if it exists. If a message is sent to several recipients, the emails can be encrypted simultaneously with the keys of all recipients and thus opened by all of them without any problems. The only minor disadvantage is that experts could identify hidden BCC recipients on the basis of the key they now use in the email. By the way, if the sender's own address is included in the distribution list, the copy sent back to the sender is also encrypted by default.
« Previous 1 2 3 Next »
Buy this article as PDF
(incl. VAT)
Buy Linux Magazine
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Fedora 41 Beta Available with Some Interesting Additions
If you're a Fedora fan, you'll be excited to hear the beta version of the latest release is now available for testing and includes plenty of updates.
-
AlmaLinux Unveils New Hardware Certification Process
The AlmaLinux Hardware Certification Program run by the Certification Special Interest Group (SIG) aims to ensure seamless compatibility between AlmaLinux and a wide range of hardware configurations.
-
Wind River Introduces eLxr Pro Linux Solution
eLxr Pro offers an end-to-end Linux solution backed by expert commercial support.
-
Juno Tab 3 Launches with Ubuntu 24.04
Anyone looking for a full-blown Linux tablet need look no further. Juno has released the Tab 3.
-
New KDE Slimbook Plasma Available for Preorder
Powered by an AMD Ryzen CPU, the latest KDE Slimbook laptop is powerful enough for local AI tasks.
-
Rhino Linux Announces Latest "Quick Update"
If you prefer your Linux distribution to be of the rolling type, Rhino Linux delivers a beautiful and reliable experience.
-
Plasma Desktop Will Soon Ask for Donations
The next iteration of Plasma has reached the soft feature freeze for the 6.2 version and includes a feature that could be divisive.
-
Linux Market Share Hits New High
For the first time, the Linux market share has reached a new high for desktops, and the trend looks like it will continue.
-
LibreOffice 24.8 Delivers New Features
LibreOffice is often considered the de facto standard office suite for the Linux operating system.
-
Deepin 23 Offers Wayland Support and New AI Tool
Deepin has been considered one of the most beautiful desktop operating systems for a long time and the arrival of version 23 has bolstered that reputation.