Writing about Diversity on the Desktop
Off the Beat: Bruce Byfield's Blog
Writing about the Linux desktop used to be simple. I wrote about GNOME and KDE, and, if I really wanted to be complete, I mentioned Xfce. Very occasionally, I might mention a few window managers. But those simple ways were lost in the fragmentation of GNOME over the last three years, and now writing about the desktop is vastly more complicated than it used to be.
Today, the number of desktop environments with significant market shares has tripled. To do a thorough job, I can no longer talk about just GNOME and KDE. At a minimum, I also need to talk about Cinnamon, Mate, Unity and Xfce -- and I'm not sure I shouldn't add LXDE and maybe a handful of others to the list.
From a user's perspective, so many choices are welcome, although possibly a little overwhelming. However, from a writer's perspective, the number of choices is nothing short of a nightmare, the type I wake from with an over-all cramp and sweat drenching the pillow. To be relevant, I want to mention all the environments that people are using, but how do I do all of them justice at the same time?
A comparative problem
Part of the problem is the amount of space. Many articles are 1000 words or less -- maybe twice that if I am lucky. Minus space for an introduction and conclusion, writing an article of typical length about KDE or GNOME means that I have about 350 words to write about each. By contrast, if I try to include all the major desktops today, each gets less than 120 words, which is so short that superficiality is guaranteed.
It gets worse, too. If I talk about more than one desktop environment in an article, I usually intend to compare them. But when I already lack space to describe each one, how can I possibly start to compare each environment to each? With two desktops, I have two comparisons to make. But with six desktops, I have an unwieldy fifteen (figure it out for yourself), and writing is constantly threatening to bog down.
But even if I manage a comparison, the techniques of comparison fall apart. Write about each desktop in a continuous passage, and either the article loses coherence, or I reduce my space for discussion by continually referring to each of the other desktop. Organize the article by features, in which I move back and forth between each desktop within each section, and I risk leaving readers (and me) in miserable confusion as I jump around. Either way, I are asking readers to endure more than they expect, and taking on more than I can hope to accomplish.
Looking for solutions
In theory, there are a few ways around these problems. In practice, though, none are consistently satisfactory.
The most obvious is to write longer articles. However, do that all the time, and I disrupt my writing schedule. Nor will print editors necessarily welcome greater lengths, since they need to balance carefully the ratio of pages devoted to articles and to ads. Even an online editor may not welcome longer articles, which disrupt their work schedule as much as the writer's.
A more promising solution is to limit Ir subject matter. For example, I can limit my discussion to GNOME derivatives, which means that I only need to talk about Cinnamon, GNOME, Mate, and Unity. Or if I are talking about GNOME 2 replacements, I can talk about only Cinnamon, GNOME Classic, and Mate. But sometimes I do want to talk about all the alternatives, and not just a sub-set.
Alternatively, I can narrow my focus to a single aspect of desktop environments, such as virtual workspaces or menus. But attempting this solution means that I risk descending to irredeemable triviality.
Still another solution is forget about comparisons altogether, and talk about each desktop environment only in isolation. The trouble is, people often do want comparisons, and personally I would hate to abandon them just because they hae become more difficult.
I've tried all these solutions, each with varying degrees of success. But even the times that I've been most successful, I work harder than I did four years ago to get the same result.
Don't get me wrong -- I like the increased choices as a user, and as a writer I'm committed to trying to do it justice. But increasingly I'm getting nostalgic for simpler times.
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Juno Computers Launches Another Linux Laptop
If you're looking for a powerhouse laptop that runs Ubuntu, the Juno Computers Neptune 17 v6 should be on your radar.
-
ZorinOS 17.1 Released, Includes Improved Windows App Support
If you need or desire to run Windows applications on Linux, there's one distribution intent on making that easier for you and its new release further improves that feature.
-
Linux Market Share Surpasses 4% for the First Time
Look out Windows and macOS, Linux is on the rise and has even topped ChromeOS to become the fourth most widely used OS around the globe.
-
KDE’s Plasma 6 Officially Available
KDE’s Plasma 6.0 "Megarelease" has happened, and it's brimming with new features, polish, and performance.
-
Latest Version of Tails Unleashed
Tails 6.0 is based on Debian 12 and includes GNOME 43.
-
KDE Announces New Slimbook V with Plenty of Power and KDE’s Plasma 6
If you're a fan of KDE Plasma, you'll be thrilled to hear they've announced a new Slimbook with an AMD CPU and the latest version of KDE Plasma desktop.
-
Monthly Sponsorship Includes Early Access to elementary OS 8
If you want to get a glimpse of what's in the pipeline for elementary OS 8, just set up a monthly sponsorship to help fund its continued existence.
-
DebConf24 to be Held in South Korea
Busan will be the location of the latest DebConf running July 28 through August 4
-
Fedora Unleashes Atomic Desktops
Fedora has combined its solid distribution with rpm-ostree system to make it possible to deliver a new family of Fedora spins, called Fedora Atomic Desktops.
-
Bootloader Vulnerability Affects Nearly All Linux Distributions
The developers of shim have released a version to fix numerous security flaws, including one that could enable remote control execution of malicious code under certain circumstances.