Zack's Kernel News
Zack's Kernel News
The Linux kernel mailing list comprises the core of Linux development activities. Traffic volumes are immense, often reaching ten thousand messages in a given week, and keeping up to date with the entire scope of development is a virtually impossible task for one person. One of the few brave souls to take on this task is Zack Brown.
Our regular monthly column keeps you abreast of the latest discussions and decisions, selected and summarized by Zack. Zack has been publishing a weekly online digest, the Kernel Traffic newsletter for over five years now. Even reading Kernel Traffic alone can be a time consuming task.
Linux Magazine now provides you with the quintessence of Linux Kernel activities, straight from the horse's mouth.
Status of HGA Framebuffer Driver
The HGA Framebuffer driver is no longer maintained. Roland Kletzing confirmed that the official maintainer, Ferenc Bakonyi, has not had the relevant hardware since 2001. Thus, the MAINTAINERS entry is completely out of date and Roland has posted a patch to remove it.
Michael Buesch has been designing and building his own hardware devices and recently asked whether he should submit drivers for that hardware or just keep them as a separate patch. The overwhelming response was, "Send in the drivers!" Apparently, as long as Michael – or anyone else – is willing to document how folks can build the hardware for themselves, the drivers for that hardware will be a welcome addition to the kernel. With that kind of encouragement, hopefully we'll start seeing a variety of unique hardware drivers appear.
Removing Firmware from the Kernel Tree
David Woodhouse wants to remove all third-party firmware out of the kernel source tree. David is in favor of letting the kernel load arbitrary blobs of firmware code (provided the resulting binary can be distributed legally under its license), but he doesn't think such things belong in the kernel. He's working on creating a separate git tree for all of them.
A number of replies dissented from this. Most folks were in favor of isolating firmware into a single location, but taking it out of the tree seemed too much because it created issues of competing firmware packages and other requirements that some folks don't want to tackle.
The most vocal opponent of David's idea was David S. Miller, who has been fighting against this idea for a while, specifically regarding the tg3 driver, which he felt needed to keep its firmware in the main tree. David Miller said that if distributions like Debian wanted to avoid any binary-only data in their kernel, it was up to them to write and maintain the necessary patches out-of-tree.
David Woodhouse responded that he'd already taken steps to ensure that even without removing the firmware, his changes would still be useful, but he did feel it would be better to take them out entirely. At this point, folks turned the discussions into a technical consideration about how the idea might be implemented. Whether some of the ideas were intended as actual suggestions or just as ruminations on what might be possible if such a thing were desired was unclear. What was clear is that a lot of folks had a variety of opinions, with many different reasons for them. In terms of what might happen with David Woodhouse's patches, I'd expect some kind of compromise. Removing the firmware is something that free software purists prefer, but it also might be something preferable for practical, legal reasons. In that case, folks like David Miller could lose the battle, but hopefully without too much inconvenience being forced on them.
Buy this article as PDF
Founder of ownCloud launches the Nextcloud project.
Will The Machine change the way future programmers think about memory?
The new Torus distributed storage system is available under an open source license on GitHub
Juries decides Google’s use of Java APIs Was Fair Use
But if you are not using the latest Linux kernel, your system is insecure.
Home routers will give room for custom firmware but still comply with FCC rules
Frank Karlitschek will continue to lead the open source ownCloud project
“Xenial Xerus” comes with a new packages format and several improvements for the enterprise.
Linux users can now download and install the Windows code editor
New initiative will address security and interoperability concerns around container technology.