Linux 2.6.25 without Closed Source USB Drivers
A controversial patch for the imminent kernel 2.6.25 is causing much debate in the developer community: in a similar move to one he made two years ago, the well-known kernel developer Greg Kroah-Hartman has submitted a patch that prevents closed source USB drivers from using the kernel's USB driver API.
Kroah-Hartman's patch has already been accepted by Linus Torvalds, and it will be part of the Git tree for the next version of Linux. It prevents closed source USB drivers from addressing the kernel's USB interface.
Originally, there were plans to introduce this barrier to the 2.6.16 kernel, but at the time vendors such as AVM GmbH protested, saying that they would cancel Linux support completely if they were not allowed to submit closed source drivers. As a result, the patch was temporarily parked to give vendors time to develop Open Source drivers, or convert their drivers to use the userspace API. The latter option gives vendors the ability to create non-GPLd drivers that will run on other systems without incommensurate effort.
Just like two years ago, the patch has been the source of much debate on the kernel mailing list. While some developers are backing Kroah-Hartman, others do not understand the move and fear that it will scare vendors off. Others see non GPL-compliant drivers in a kind of legal limbo.
The case is quite clear for Kroah-Hartman, however: the obstacle would not cause any issues as he is unaware of any USB drivers in the Wild that the patch would actually affect. Developer Christer Weinigel objects that many closed source USB drivers are the results of bespoke programming and are thus not available in the Wild. Kroah-Hartman's answer to this is that the userspace interface would be fine for drivers of this kind, and that even military users have successfully tapped this API. Kroah-Hartman has been quoted as saying that tanks run on Linux. Developer Pekka Enberg refers developers who insist on the kernel interface to another system, saying they should use BSD or a proprietary operating system.
Issue 230/2020
Buy this issue as a PDF
News
-
Linux Mint 19.3 Will be Released by Christmas
The developers behind Linux Mint have announced 19.3 will be released by Christmas 2019.
-
Linux Kernel 5.4 Released
A number of new changes and improvements have reached the Linux kernel.
-
System76 To Design And Build Laptops In-House
In-house designed and built laptops coming from System76.
-
News and views on the GPU revolution in HPC and Big Data:
-
The PinePhone Pre-Order has Arrived
Anyone looking to finally get their hands on an early release of the PinePhone can do so as of November 15.
-
Microsoft Edge Coming to Linux
Microsoft is bringing it’s new Chromium-based Edge browser to Linux.
-
Open Invention Network Backs Gnome Project Against Patent Troll
OIN has deployed its legal team to find prior art.
-
Fedora 31 Released
The latest version of Fedora comes with new packages and libraries.
-
openSUSE OBS Can Now Build Windows WSL Images
openSUSE enables developers to build their own WSL distributions.
-
Sudo Vulnerability
A vulnerability in the sudo package gives sudo users more powers than they deserve.