U.S. Courts: New Criteria for Software Patents
A current U.S. court case would make it harder for software patent trolls to file for dubious patents and make legal claims based on existing ones.
In what has been termed the Bilski Case (or simply "Bilski"), a U.S. Federal Circuit Court of Appeals handed down a ruling that redefined how software can be patented. The case surrounded how far a marketable idea can be protected, based on the patent filing of Bernard Bilski and Rand Warsaw, who had founded a company named Weatherwise and wanted to protect their ideas on processing weather risk data. Some patent lawyers considered the case similar to one involving software. To present just such an argument in terms of Free and Open Source Software (FOSS), U.S. Linux distributor Red Hat submitted an amicus curiae brief in response to the appeal, with the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) following up closely behind. In the opinion of the law platform Groklaw, these briefs contributed considerably to the Bilski appeal ruling, with positive ramifications for free and open source software.
The Appeals Court rejected the Bilski appeal by ruling that the patent idea did not produce "useful, concrete and tangible results" and used this as a gauge for future patent considerations. FOSS representatives (Red Hat lawyers among them) have felt that a lack of this gauge has led to countless frivolous patent applications in the past. Although the court did not settle the issue specifically of how or when software is patentable, it did pave the way by setting some new guidelines and criteria. Red Hat responded to the court decision and described its consequences for the FOSS community in a press release.
The court dropped the previous software patent criteria (which had produced a wave of claims in the late 1990s) in favor of two new ones. To make a process patentable, they ruled, it must be "tied to a particular machine or apparatus" or it must "transform a particular article into a different state or thing." Depending on how broadly "tied to a particular machine" is interpreted, the effect could be significant for future patentability claims. If interpreted too broadly, tenuous ties between software and a general purpose computer would do little to discourage future patent claims. However, FOSS advocates cited past patent cases where the "particular machine" argument as related to a general purpose computer failed to hold up in court. In the dissenting opinion of Bilski Judge Newman, "For the thousands of inventors who obtained patents under the court’s now-discarded criteria, their property rights are now vulnerable."
Nevertheless, FOSS lawyers see the decision as a good basis for changes to patent laws. They caution, however, that the software world will have to figure on increasing lobbying efforts from past patent seekers and "beneficiaries of the status quo." The Red Hat press release ends on a positive note with "We have a battle before us, but it is a battle we can win."
Issue 230/2020
Buy this issue as a PDF
News
-
Elementary OS 5.1 Has Arrived
One of the most highly regarded Linux desktop distributions has released its next iteration.
-
Linux Mint 19.3 Will be Released by Christmas
The developers behind Linux Mint have announced 19.3 will be released by Christmas 2019.
-
Linux Kernel 5.4 Released
A number of new changes and improvements have reached the Linux kernel.
-
System76 To Design And Build Laptops In-House
In-house designed and built laptops coming from System76.
-
News and views on the GPU revolution in HPC and Big Data:
-
The PinePhone Pre-Order has Arrived
Anyone looking to finally get their hands on an early release of the PinePhone can do so as of November 15.
-
Microsoft Edge Coming to Linux
Microsoft is bringing it’s new Chromium-based Edge browser to Linux.
-
Open Invention Network Backs Gnome Project Against Patent Troll
OIN has deployed its legal team to find prior art.
-
Fedora 31 Released
The latest version of Fedora comes with new packages and libraries.
-
openSUSE OBS Can Now Build Windows WSL Images
openSUSE enables developers to build their own WSL distributions.