Write Access

Write Access

© Stefan Habersack, Fotolia

© Stefan Habersack, Fotolia

 

Bash 4 Compatibility

Your article on the new Bash version 4.0 (August 2009, pg. 62) refers to the topic of compatibility right at the start, pointing to eight changes introduced for the sake of POSIX compatibility. Chet Ramey also seems to have been referring to this in your interview, when he said that the new version was as downwardly compatible as possible, but version 3.2's behavior was just incorrect in some places.

In version 4.0 of the shell, the $@ and $* parameter lists are fairly inconsistent "semi-variables" (bash -uc 'echo $@' "$@:unbound variable"; but: @=1 @=1: command not found), although this is not mentioned in the COMPAT file.

These changes mark a departure of the new shell from the POSIX standard, which clearly states: "If there are no positional parameters, the expansion of '@' shall generate zero fields [...]."

Bash 4 simply treats $@ and $* as "undefined" if no parameters have been passed in. This problem primarily occurs when the nounset option (-u) is used to protect against the use of undefined variables and thus make scripts more secure and robust. In this light, the problem might only affect a couple of programmers, as most people still unfortunately work without nounset. (-u is not even mentioned in the Bash manpage.) However, it is quite conceivable that this new behavior could cause other problems that are still waiting to be discovered.

In my opinion, these changes are a careless step backwards and do not indicate the kind of diligence in release management you would expect from a critical package like Bash. This is the reason why I declared the changes to be a grave bug on the following Debian bug report site: http://bugs.debian.org/519165

Martin F Krafft

LM

Bernard Bablok, the author of the Bash 4 article, writes:

I am not familiar with the particular issue described in this letter, but I will assume that Martin Krafft is right. Even so, I cannot share his assessment of Bash 4 as a "careless step backwards." In a complex program such as Bash, it can happen that a compatibility issue or an unwanted problem creeps in. There are bug lists and mailing lists in order to clarify or change such things.

Thanks for your letter. We'll hope the bug report you filed with Debian will draw some attention to this issue.

ECIS and EC

Contrary to an article in your magazine (see "Microsoft's Anticompetitive Behavior" July 2009, pg. 10), ECIS is not part of the European Commission.

They are a lobby group.

Could you please print a correction and amend the online version?

Jonathan Todd European Commission Spokesman on Competition

Read full article as PDF:

Related content

  • Bash 4

    Despite the Bourne-again shell's biblical age and high level of maturity, developers continue to work on it. We take a look at the latest Bash release.

  • Command Line

    A few basic tricks can liven up the command line and add a dash of color to your console.

  • Bash Builtins

    Even beginners can benefit from a greater understanding of the Bash shell’s many builtin commands.

  • Samba Team Receives Microsoft Protocol Docs

    Today the Protocol Freedom Information Foundation (PFIF), a non-profit organization created by the Software Freedom Law Center, signed an agreement with Microsoft to receive the protocol documentation needed to fully interoperate with the Microsoft Windows workgroup server products and to make them available to Free Software projects such as Samba.

  • Commission Fines Microsoft 899 m Euros

    The European Commission has imposed a fine of 899 m Euros on Microsoft, stating that the company had demanded unreasonable prices for interface documentation for it Workgroup servers.

comments powered by Disqus

Direct Download

Read full article as PDF:

News

njobs Europe
What:
Where:
Country:
Njobs Netherlands Njobs Deutschland Njobs United Kingdom Njobs Italia Njobs France Njobs Espana Njobs Poland
Njobs Austria Njobs Denmark Njobs Belgium Njobs Czech Republic Njobs Mexico Njobs India Njobs Colombia