Defining Free Hardware

Off the Beat: Bruce Byfield's Blog
Most Linux users have heard of the Four Freedoms that define free software. But where is the corresponding free hardware definition?
The Open Source Hardware Association (OSHWA) has tried to develop one, but it is unsatisfactory for two reasons. First, it is too verbose, and like many documents written by committee, somewhat disorganized.
Second, as I realized when writing about Len Leighton's EOMA68 laptop, a free hardware definition needs to be oriented towards giving all users control over their computing. Free software's Four Freedoms can ignore this aspect, because only programmers generally exercise them, but free hardware will be used by people with all levels of expertise.
With these points in mind, here is my attempt at a definition of free hardware. It is not meant to be definitive so much as to encourage discussion of what I believe is an increasingly important topic:
1. Free hardware must use free software to operate for everything from firmware to user interfaces. This is a difficult goal, especially since computer chips rarely use free software, but I am talking about the ideal. A manufacturer may choose, of course, to have different models of the same device, some that meet the definition of freedom and some that do not.
2 .Free hardware must use free standards. Users must be able to choose the hardware of their choice, instead of being restricted to a certain manufacturer's hardware.
3. Free hardware must be designed so that any part of it is accessible and replaceable by users. In many cases, this requirement might be best met by a module design that allows replacement parts to be swapped in and out with difficulty. However, sealed cases of the kind often found in tablets and phones are unacceptable
4. Free hardware must include free and complete documentation of every aspect from integrated circuit boards and .stl files for 3D printing of parts (if applicable) to user guides. This requirement can almost be ignored in free software, but in free hardware it can be an absolute necessity if users are going to have full control.
5. Free hardware must be built to last, and not designed for planned obsolescence that forces users onto an upgrade treadmill. Individual parts should be replaceable without replacing the entire device. Whenever possible, it may use recycled parts, frames of bamboo or plywood, modular construction, or anything that keeps pieces out of land-fill -- naturally, the more the better. New releases should occur only when genuinely new designs or features are added, and be as backwardly compatible as possible.
In isolation, some of these conditions may seem peripheral to the definition. However, keep in mind that the point is to allow users the greatest amount of freedom and control possible, and they should make more sense.
Similarly, if the standards are high, trying to follow them will produce better results than if they are relaxed. If a device falls short of these standards, It may at least be freer than if the standards were lower. The Broadcom chip in the Raspberry Pi, for example, is not completely free, but it is freer than it would have been if the manufacturers had not made an effort for as much freedom as possible.
However, I consider the free hardware definition a work in progress, so if you have any additions or corrections, I would appreciate hearing them.
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.

News
-
First Release Candidate for Linux Kernel 6.14 Now Available
Linus Torvalds has officially released the first release candidate for kernel 6.14 and it includes over 500,000 lines of modified code, making for a small release.
-
System76 Refreshes Meerkat Mini PC
If you're looking for a small form factor PC powered by Linux, System76 has exactly what you need in the Meerkat mini PC.
-
Gnome 48 Alpha Ready for Testing
The latest Gnome desktop alpha is now available with plenty of new features and improvements.
-
Wine 10 Includes Plenty to Excite Users
With its latest release, Wine has the usual crop of bug fixes and improvements, along with some exciting new features.
-
Linux Kernel 6.13 Offers Improvements for AMD/Apple Users
The latest Linux kernel is now available, and it includes plenty of improvements, especially for those who use AMD or Apple-based systems.
-
Gnome 48 Debuts New Audio Player
To date, the audio player found within the Gnome desktop has been meh at best, but with the upcoming release that all changes.
-
Plasma 6.3 Ready for Public Beta Testing
Plasma 6.3 will ship with KDE Gear 24.12.1 and KDE Frameworks 6.10, along with some new and exciting features.
-
Budgie 10.10 Scheduled for Q1 2025 with a Surprising Desktop Update
If Budgie is your desktop environment of choice, 2025 is going to be a great year for you.
-
Firefox 134 Offers Improvements for Linux Version
Fans of Linux and Firefox rejoice, as there's a new version available that includes some handy updates.
-
Serpent OS Arrives with a New Alpha Release
After months of silence, Ikey Doherty has released a new alpha for his Serpent OS.