Linux Voice News Analysis
Linux Voice News Analysis

Open source is for you, yes, but it's also for unknown others.
Opinion
Unknown Others
Being close to an open source project, it's easy to imagine that everyone sees the project the way you and your fellow community members do. This especially applies to the corporate sponsors of a single-company project; anticipating use by competitors, they often want to apply controls to who can use the code.
A core objective of software freedom is to ensure that the code can be used not only by your collaborators, but by unknown others with undisclosed goals. All OSI-approved licenses ensure everyone is permitted to use software for any purpose without further permission, delivering this core objective.
Random code liberation leading to unexpected application (aka "innovation") has always been and will remain a hallmark of open source. Borrowing portions of great code – from elegantly executed algorithms to useful libraries to entire components – is an intended mode of exercise for software freedom and not an artifact. Leaving it available is essential.
The same provisions that allow code reuse also enable the crucial pressure release valve of open source: the fork. The ability to take the code and do something the original author or the current community don't want is an essential freedom, not an unwanted side effect. Indeed, it is the origin of many of the most significant moments in open source.
It was a fork that rescued OpenOffice.org from corporate neglect, giving us LibreOffice. A fork allowed ForgeRock to rescue Sun's identity management software from abandonment, thus saving huge investments in its deployment and creating a highly valued "unicorn" startup in the process. The MariaDB fork is keeping the MySQL project focused on community. Even the Firefox browser was a kind of fork from Mozilla, albeit a strategic one.
Making open source code freely available to unknown others is thus axial and not tangential to open source. That's why I get extremely concerned by anything that wants to be seen as "open source" but still tries to lock out the outsiders, the rebels, and the aliens. Attempts to do this range from the crude, like using a "time-locked" license that only becomes open source after a significant delay for "monetization," to more subtle approaches, like requiring an account to access the source repository and then only allowing paying customers to have an account.
The code may be under an open source license, but software freedom is not present if accessing or using it requires being or knowing an insider. None of this is theoretical; indeed, ForgeRock and MariaDB are themselves playing these games despite their origin story being rooted in software freedom.
So remain skeptical when software freedom is abridged or diminished in pursuit of a business model or "safety." Whatever that's called, it's not open source.
Buy this article as PDF
(incl. VAT)
Buy Linux Magazine
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you've found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
The GNU Project Celebrates Its 40th Birthday
September 27 marks the 40th anniversary of the GNU Project, and it was celebrated with a hacker meeting in Biel/Bienne, Switzerland.
-
Linux Kernel Reducing Long-Term Support
LTS support for the Linux kernel is about to undergo some serious changes that will have a considerable impact on the future.
-
Fedora 39 Beta Now Available for Testing
For fans and users of Fedora Linux, the first beta of release 39 is now available, which is a minor upgrade but does include GNOME 45.
-
Fedora Linux 40 to Drop X11 for KDE Plasma
When Fedora 40 arrives in 2024, there will be a few big changes coming, especially for the KDE Plasma option.
-
Real-Time Ubuntu Available in AWS Marketplace
Anyone looking for a Linux distribution for real-time processing could do a whole lot worse than Real-Time Ubuntu.
-
KSMBD Finally Reaches a Stable State
For those who've been looking forward to the first release of KSMBD, after two years it's no longer considered experimental.
-
Nitrux 3.0.0 Has Been Released
The latest version of Nitrux brings plenty of innovation and fresh apps to the table.
-
Linux From Scratch 12.0 Now Available
If you're looking to roll your own Linux distribution, the latest version of Linux From Scratch is now available with plenty of updates.
-
Linux Kernel 6.5 Has Been Released
The newest Linux kernel, version 6.5, now includes initial support for two very exciting features.
-
UbuntuDDE 23.04 Now Available
A new version of the UbuntuDDE remix has finally arrived with all the updates from the Deepin desktop and everything that comes with the Ubuntu 23.04 base.