CopyWrong!
![Jon Jon](/var/linux_magazin/storage/images/online/blogs/paw-prints-writings-of-the-maddog/275394-9-eng-US/Paw-Prints-Writings-of-the-maddog.png)
Paw Prints: Writings of the maddog
Last month I briefly blogged about my love affair with old automated musical instruments such as the player piano, player reed organ, nickelodeon, wind-up phonographs and my long association with the Automatic Musical Instrument Collector's Association (AMICA).
June, 2008 was the first time that I was able to physically attend a local chapter of the AMICA, and I enjoyed meeting other people who collected and played these ancient instruments. One of the downsides of collecting the older paper-driven instruments is that in a lot of cases the paper, sometimes made with an acid-based wash, is deteriorating and some of the members are trying desperately to preserve this old music by copying the rolls, or by capturing the information into MIDI files or mpeg-3 files. These files are then put on the Internet for others to enjoy, allowing others to hear recordings of songs which the companies that produced the rolls have long been out of business.
I thought about this procedure of preserving this music, and felt there were a lot of songs that I had in my collection that I could put up on the Internet. People could then hear the sound of my instruments playing, as well as hear the music itself. As a Free Software person and a follower of the issues around copyright I would be careful to use a melodie that was long out of copyright, like "Greensleeves". But something in the back of my mind began to nag me, so I sent email to one company who still manufactures player piano rolls and asked to talk to their legal department.
A very nice and patient man answered the phone, and I explained what I wanted to do. I explained that I would be sure to use a song that was an ancient melodie which had to be out of copyright by now, and I only wanted to do a few songs, perhaps "Greensleeves" and some ragtime melody that used a mechanism in my player piano called the "mandolin". The nice man replied that Greensleeves was indeed out of copyright, but that the artist's rendition of my Greensleeves roll might not be out of copyright. I began to feel the hackles on the back of my neck stand up.
The nice man continued by saying that the rendition of Greensleeves had been put onto a roll of paper, and that too included a copyright, so other player piano roll manufacturers would not just buy one roll, copy it, and sell it to other player piano owners.
Then the nice man mentioned the "Phonorecord copyright act of 1972”, which to me has always been as clear as mud, and which made this issue of rescuing an ancient song cut into fast-decomposing paper even foggier.
We ended up agreeing that if I made an mp3 recording of less than 30 seconds, off an old roll, from a company that was completely out of business, kept it completely for my own use and locked up so no one else could hear it, that I probably would not be sued. He also begged me not to use any of his company rolls in this task, as he really did not want to have to sue me. I thanked him for his time.
On the other hand I have stopped singing "Greensleeves", even when alone in the shower, and have not been heard to sing “Happy Birthday” in public for years.
Carpe Diem!
Comments
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
![Learn More](https://www.linux-magazine.com/var/linux_magazin/storage/images/media/linux-magazine-eng-us/images/misc/learn-more/834592-1-eng-US/Learn-More_medium.png)
News
-
NVIDIA Released Driver for Upcoming NVIDIA 560 GPU for Linux
Not only has NVIDIA released the driver for its upcoming CPU series, it's the first release that defaults to using open-source GPU kernel modules.
-
OpenMandriva Lx 24.07 Released
If you’re into rolling release Linux distributions, OpenMandriva ROME has a new snapshot with a new kernel.
-
Kernel 6.10 Available for General Usage
Linus Torvalds has released the 6.10 kernel and it includes significant performance increases for Intel Core hybrid systems and more.
-
TUXEDO Computers Releases InfinityBook Pro 14 Gen9 Laptop
Sporting either AMD or Intel CPUs, the TUXEDO InfinityBook Pro 14 is an extremely compact, lightweight, sturdy powerhouse.
-
Google Extends Support for Linux Kernels Used for Android
Because the LTS Linux kernel releases are so important to Android, Google has decided to extend the support period beyond that offered by the kernel development team.
-
Linux Mint 22 Stable Delayed
If you're anxious about getting your hands on the stable release of Linux Mint 22, it looks as if you're going to have to wait a bit longer.
-
Nitrux 3.5.1 Available for Install
The latest version of the immutable, systemd-free distribution includes an updated kernel and NVIDIA driver.
-
Debian 12.6 Released with Plenty of Bug Fixes and Updates
The sixth update to Debian "Bookworm" is all about security mitigations and making adjustments for some "serious problems."
-
Canonical Offers 12-Year LTS for Open Source Docker Images
Canonical is expanding its LTS offering to reach beyond the DEB packages with a new distro-less Docker image.
-
Plasma Desktop 6.1 Released with Several Enhancements
If you're a fan of Plasma Desktop, you should be excited about this new point release.
Archive,org's music collection
One thing that occurs to me is that archive.org is building an archival collection of mp3's of 78 RPM records, including making them publicly available. They haven't been asked to stop or to pull items, and must have addressed this issue.
The MP3s and/or MIDI of the player rolls would certainly be as valid for preservation as the 78 RPM records.
Perhaps they would be a good resource to consult about the legalities, and might be willing to host copies of the archived rolls.
US Copywrong laws
The dates appear to be carefilly set so W**t D****y Inc(* to avoid copyright) can 'rip off' any classical music/books it likes without paying royalties BUT nobody can copy M***y M***e.
Love Americans BUT HATE US.Politicians and Mega Corps.
Robbin
A message to keep 2nd and 3rd cousins from bothering you
Something like this keeps the dilettantes and crazies away. It does not say "f--k off," simply "please don't waste my time if you aren't the copyright owner."
"All of the material in this archive is unavailable commercially and is being offered for archival and historical purposes only. Any commercial reuse of the material is unauthorized. If you claim copyright on materials here and you wish them removed, please contact [email addr here]. I will ask you to supply proof of ownership. A notarized copyright registration certificate is your best bet. If your claim is valid and verified, the materials will be removed immediately. "
Not in the U.S.... so U.S. copyright law doesn't really apply
Of course if you are out of the U.S. to start with, ignore the U.S. rules from day 1 and follow those of your own country, whatever nation that might be.
Thanks for everyone's comments
As to Scott's comment: Scott, in copying the rolls we were trying to do three things: Show people what the instrument was like, preserve the music, and expose people to these long-dead artists. The first could be done through midi and playing the actual instrument as you suggested. The archival copy could probably be justified. The third might be done by the "30 second" rule.
Or we can just put some limited number of recordings up and wait for someone to tell us to take them down.
X
Preservation copies?
If the same law controls rolls as does sound recordings (and I assume it would), you are probably pretty screwed as it gives precedence to STATE copyright laws.
Copy and Educate
Myself, I'd do as I damn well pleased, and keep it to myself.
Would this approach work?