The Ada Initiative leaves a mixed record behind it

Off the Beat: Bruce Byfield's Blog
I was one of the first to write about the Ada Initiative. I was also (as Anonymous Donor #1) -- the first to donate to it, and the first to resign from its advisory board. I've passed through personal distaste and disillusion to indifference, but, having written about The Ada Initiative's start, I feel an obligation to write about its end, and the legacies it leaves behind.
The Ada Initiative was founded as a response to a sexual assault on Noirin Plunkett. Appropriately, the announcement of its end comes a day after Plunkett's memorial service. But you could have predicted what was about to happen for a couple of months.
Long-time advisers resigned, and were keeping feminist solidarity by not explaining why. A new executive director also resigned, and no effort was made to replace her. The popular AdaCamps were canceled. Little was being heard from Mary Gardiner, one of the founders. Meanwhile, Valerie Aurora, the other director, was consulting a career counsellor.
During all these events, the Ada Initiative itself was largely inactive. Although only four months ago, the Ada Initiative appeared to be thriving, the combination of events was suggestive long before the official announcement.
Top-down feminism
So what happened? I am not on speaking terms with anyone involved with The Ada Initiative -- criticism being anathema to them -- but I can make some guesses based on observation. In theory, nothing would have prevented The Ada Initiative from continuing, and the early responses to the news suggest no shortage of people who would help it survive. However, the Ada Initiative was never likely to outlive the interest of its founders.
From my first contact with the founders, my impression was that The Ada Initiative was based upon personal ambition centered around activism. Nothing is innately wrong with that combination -- in fact, in some respects I find it admirable -- but in this case it was accompanied by a need to control, and a reluctance to delegate or compromise.
Looking back, I suggest that this reluctance seriously hindered The Ada Initiative's growth. It led to a reluctance to accept most corporate funding, and made relatively simple projects like an unconference more complicated by the insistence on vetting attendees. Directors, advisers, and contractors appear to have been chosen from selected friends of the founders. Look through the Ada Initiative's blogs, especially in the early days, and you can hardly miss the tendency to tell people how to organize their lives and how to think.
This tendency is even spelled out on the web page of Double Union, a feminist hacker space co-founded by Aurora and whose members include many involved with The Ada Initiative. The group spells out the orthodoxies expected of members, and makes clear that even devil's advocacy is not permitted -- apparently on the grounds that it could be a refuge for trolls.
The tendency might be annoying in itself. However, its worst consequences were public relation disasters. For example, kernel hacker Ted T'so was condemned for ill-informed comments about rape statistics made a couple of years previously, leading to him being described as a "rape apologist" by an Ada Initiative supporter. Similarly, Aurora advocated the distribution of "creeper cards" in response to sexist actions and comments, until they were laughed out of existence, after which reporting on the cards became more neutral on the Ada Initiative's site. Such instances seriously damaged the group's reputation, losing the good will of potential supporters.
However, the most notorious of these disasters was forcing the cancellation of Violet Blue's talk at BSides San Francisco in 2013. Whether the cancellation was part of a publicity stunt or an honest mistake, The Ada Initiative's unconvincing self-defense was enough to ensure that it would never be taken seriously in the security industry ever again. With one rash action, the goodwill generated by over a year of work in the industry was lost. In fact, at the next Defcon, the organization was a running joke
Given the attitudes that generated such problems, the internal conflicts of the last few months may have been viewed by the founders as a betrayal of trust. Rebuilding the organization would have meant risking similar problems with delegation. Under such circumstances, what else was left except to close down? Lingering to create legacy organizations would have been a prolonged transfer of control, while continuing the group's activities unaided would be a step backwards to The Ada Initiative's earliest days. Either would be a reminder of failure that would sit poorly with the ambition that was never far away.
The Legacy, Pro and Con
These actions and inactions mean that the Ada Initiative leaves a mixed record. The group's publicity disasters might have harmed the cause of feminism as much as its activities helped.
For that matter, how should anyone judge its main activities: encouraging anti-harassment policies for conferences, holding AdaCamps for women, and teaching workshops for allies and overcoming impostor syndrome? They seem disturbingly minor for the hundreds of thousands of dollars spent on them, especially when all the other issues facing women in the workplace are considered.
We cannot even be sure that anti-harassment policies are anything more than security theater, reassuring without adding to anyone's safety. Like similar policies of the 1990s, they may soon be forgotten.
As for impostor syndrome, it is not even a recognized psychiatric condition, and The Ada Initiative's teachings seem to be more about self-esteem than about developing competence. It suggests, for example, seeking reassurance from friends when a more concrete approach might stress how women might demonstrate their ability to both themselves and their colleagues.
Yet against these concerns must be set the fact that, one way or the other, The Ada Initiative raised the consciousness (to use a term from feminism's second wave) of hundreds of women and men. It has helped reveal the systemic sexism in the tech industry, and that awareness, once required, cannot be lost short of amnesia or senility. The best result of The Ada Initiative's demise would be the rise of dozens of groups to take its place, creating the mass movement that its founders dreamed about but were incapable of building themselves.
I have been expecting the end of The Ada Initiative for some weeks now, but being right gives me no satisfaction. Despite disagreements, I have always preferred The Ada Initiative to its misogynist opponents. But mostly, the news leaves me with a sense of disappointment, of opportunities lost that should have been seized, and the hope that something might still be salvaged after so many false steps.
Note: This article has been modified in response to comments in order to make its points clearer.
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.

News
-
openSUSE Tumbleweed Ditches AppArmor for SELinux
If you're an openSUSE Tumbleweed user, you can expect a major change to the distribution.
-
Plasma 6.3 Now Available
Plasma desktop v6.3 has a couple of pretty nifty tricks up its sleeve.
-
LibreOffice 25.2 Has Arrived
If you've been hoping for a release that offers more UI customizations, you're in for a treat.
-
TuxCare Has a Big AlmaLinux 9 Announcement in Store
TuxCare announced it has successfully completed a Security Technical Implementation Guide for AlmaLinux OS 9.
-
First Release Candidate for Linux Kernel 6.14 Now Available
Linus Torvalds has officially released the first release candidate for kernel 6.14 and it includes over 500,000 lines of modified code, making for a small release.
-
System76 Refreshes Meerkat Mini PC
If you're looking for a small form factor PC powered by Linux, System76 has exactly what you need in the Meerkat mini PC.
-
Gnome 48 Alpha Ready for Testing
The latest Gnome desktop alpha is now available with plenty of new features and improvements.
-
Wine 10 Includes Plenty to Excite Users
With its latest release, Wine has the usual crop of bug fixes and improvements, along with some exciting new features.
-
Linux Kernel 6.13 Offers Improvements for AMD/Apple Users
The latest Linux kernel is now available, and it includes plenty of improvements, especially for those who use AMD or Apple-based systems.
-
Gnome 48 Debuts New Audio Player
To date, the audio player found within the Gnome desktop has been meh at best, but with the upcoming release that all changes.