Klaus Knopper answers your Linux questions
Ask Klaus

Migrating a Linux OS from DVD to flash.
Klaus: I am a newbie, and I have an XPS Dell laptop in excellent condition (still rather new, about a year old) except for ONE THING – it has "buggy" Windows 8 on it. I'd like to wipe the laptop's hard drive and do a full, non-partition installation of Linux using a CD supplied by Linux Pro Magazine. However, my laptop does not have a CD/DVD drive but rather has two USB 3.0 ports.
I do have a Dell XPS Studio 9100 desktop running Windows 7 Professional, and it does have a CD drive. That having been said, can I simply insert the CD, open a My Computer window, click and drag the contents to an empty flash drive, then transfer the flash drive to my laptop where I can do a clean install of Linux?
There must be a good reason that Linux OS installations in magazines are on CDs rather than on flash drives, but I'd like to know why.
Thanks for any advice you can offer.
Sincerely, Terrell
First, a word about CDs and DVDs as add-ons to magazines: It is true that a more modern way would be to include USB flash disks rather than DVDs. However, a DVD does not add significant cost to the production, and the process of gluing the DVD holder into the print medium is technically well supported. Inserting a USB flash disk would increase the price of the magazine so that readers who buy the magazine for the written content, and not especially for the included software, would face a price challenge that might not be acceptable.
Apart from the significantly higher production cost, mass-flashing USB drives is a more time-intensive task. CDs and DVDs are printed in a production line within a day, but "bulk flashing" requires manual insertion and removal, as well as verification of the content, which further increases the time and cost needed for production. So, it looks like we will have DVDs around as the primary "physical software container" for a while, even though drives are getting rare.
An obvious solution to your problem could be to attach a USB DVD drive or burner to the computer's USB port. The BIOS and even UEFI firmware of most computers will detect the drive and allow booting from it using the standard "El Torito" method [1].
Please note that booting from DVD differs from booting a disk or flash disk. A DVD does not have a "master boot record" but uses a special structure that tells the computer's BIOS where the bootloader is located. Therefore, just copying over the CD's content to a USB flash disk is not going to make it a bootable device. The flash drive needs its own version of a bootloader. Luckily, some tools provide an easy migration from DVD or CD to the flash medium or allow you to download Linux installation software directly to USB:
- UNetbootin – This tool creates bootable installation USB drives for various Linux distributions. UNetbootin is also open source software, and it runs on Windows, Linux, and Mac OS [3] (see Figure 2).
- Pen Drive Linux offers a collection of USB installation tools online [4].
- Knoppix provides its own USB flash installer, flash-knoppix [5], which also allows you to encrypt personal data in the Live system or run updates on the flash drive, but it's strictly Knoppix-specific (Figure 3).
If your computer gives you the choice, switching from UEFI mode to CSM (Compatibility Support Module, or the "normal" BIOS boot) will make installation of Linux distributions and booting from Live media easier.
Infos
- El Torito bootable CD specification: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Torito_(CD-ROM_standard)<
- Rufus: http://rufus.akeo.ie/
- UNetbootin: http://unetbootin.sourceforge.net/
- USB tools: http://www.pendrivelinux.com/
- flash-knoppix: http://www.knopper.net/knoppix/knoppix742-en.html#nodvd
Buy this article as PDF
(incl. VAT)
Buy Linux Magazine
Direct Download
Read full article as PDF:
Price $2.95
News
-
The First Point Release For Ubuntu 22.04 is Now Available
Canonical has released the first point upgrade for Jammy Jellyfish which includes important new toolchains and fixes.
-
Kali Linux 2022.3 Released
From the creators of the most popular penetration testing distributions on the planet, comes a new release with some new tools and a community, real-time chat option.
-
The 14" Pinebook Pro Linux Laptop is Shipping
After a considerable delay, the 14" version of the Pinebook Pro laptop is, once again, available for purchase.
-
OpenMandriva Lx ROME Technical Preview Released
OpenMandriva’s rolling release distribution technical preview has been released for testing purposes and adds some of the latest/greatest software into the mix.
-
Linux Mint 21 is Now Available
The latest iteration of Linux Mint, codenamed Vanessa, has been released with a new upgrade tool and other fantastic features.
-
Firefox Adds Long-Anticipated Feature
Firefox 103 has arrived and it now includes a feature users have long awaited…sort of.
-
System76 Refreshes Their Popular Oryx Pro Laptop with a New CPU
The System76 Oryx Pro laptop has been relaunched with a 12th Gen CPU and more powerful graphics options.
-
Elive Has Released a New Beta
The Elive team is proud to announce the latest beta version (3.8.30) of its Enlightenment-centric Linux distribution.
-
Rocky Linux 9 Has Arrived
The latest iteration of Rocky Linux is now available and includes a host of new features and support for new architecture.
-
Slimbook Executive Linux Ultrabook Upgrading Their CPUs
The Spanish-based company, Slimbook, has made available their next generation Slimbook Executive Linux ultrabooks with a 12th Gen Intel Alder Lake CPU.