Password-free authentication – FIDO2 and WebAuthn
Hardware
A partner of the FIDO Alliance, StrongKey (formerly StrongAuth) [20], advertises its Enterprise Solution Key Appliance with high data security (Figure 4). For $3,000, the FIDO Fast Start offer meets NIST requirements and is "designed specifically for government agencies." If you ignore all the marketing and buzzword bingo, the StrongKey feature list looks good.
A Fast Start test seems to be the cheapest way in: Web apps developed for this purpose must support Chrome 50 or newer, must not use a captcha or one-time password, and must be limited to one URL – reloading external resources is prohibited. This setup should work fine with a Yubikey token or a smartphone or laptop with biometric devices.
Criticism
FIDO2 seems to be a good combination of usability, security, and standardization. Supported by large corporations and organizations (e.g., from the credit card industry), the standard could spread rapidly – especially with the availability of ready-made, inexpensive hardware appliances.
The open source communities around Mozilla and Google (Chrome and Android) and the Apple and Microsoft communities also have done their homework and are driving the standard forward. For companies, especially, the combination of biometrics – despite all the inherent technological weaknesses – and tokens seems attractive, especially in the ongoing trend toward web services and cloud apps. However, the financial sector is likely to be the driving force. Presumably, many banking and credit card functions will be available soon with WebAuthn, as well.
Weaknesses
Because FIDO2 and WebAuthn authentication occurs in the browser, attacks on the browser are likely to remain the focus. According to the FIDO Alliance, WebAuthn is protected against man-in-the-middle and phishing attacks.
Expected problems are also hidden in the use of biometrics and credential recovery: The use of biometrics in place of passwords is risky. Iris scans, fingerprints, or keyboard and typing behavior should only replace the username, not the password. If one fingerprint is compromised, the user has only nine others. Moreover, users leave their fingerprints everywhere in everyday life, present their iris to every high-definition camera, and demonstrate their typing behavior to every web service.
Apart from these fundamental concerns, biometrics seem to be used sensibly in this case. The fingerprint only gives the authorization to generate the key within the presence display.
The problem of common password procedures ("Can I trust the server?") can only be solved with individual passwords per service. At the end of the day, the WebAuthn procedure does a good deal to help – without a password manager – but it makes credential memory a single point of failure that is likely to be the target of attacks.
Computer-independent analog storage of long, cryptic passwords generated per service is often even more secure, but who wants to put up with that today? WebAuthn's approach is therefore going in the right direction: more security with appropriate usability. But it also has weaknesses.
« Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »
Buy this article as PDF
(incl. VAT)
Buy Linux Magazine
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you've found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Fedora 39 Beta is Now Available for Testing
For fans and users of Fedora Linux, the first beta of release 39 is now available, which is a minor upgrade but does include GNOME 45.
-
Fedora Linux 40 to Drop X11 for KDE Plasma
When Fedora 40 arrives in 2024, there will be a few big changes coming, especially for the KDE Plasma option.
-
Real-Time Ubuntu Available in AWS Marketplace
Anyone looking for a Linux distribution for real-time processing could do a whole lot worse than Real-Time Ubuntu.
-
KSMBD Finally Reaches a Stable State
For those who've been looking forward to the first release of KSMBD, after two years it's no longer considered experimental.
-
Nitrux 3.0.0 Has Been Released
The latest version of Nitrux brings plenty of innovation and fresh apps to the table.
-
Linux From Scratch 12.0 Now Available
If you're looking to roll your own Linux distribution, the latest version of Linux From Scratch is now available with plenty of updates.
-
Linux Kernel 6.5 Has Been Released
The newest Linux kernel, version 6.5, now includes initial support for two very exciting features.
-
UbuntuDDE 23.04 Now Available
A new version of the UbuntuDDE remix has finally arrived with all the updates from the Deepin desktop and everything that comes with the Ubuntu 23.04 base.
-
Star Labs Reveals a New Surface-Like Linux Tablet
If you've ever wanted a tablet that rivals the MS Surface, you're in luck as Star Labs has created such a device.
-
SUSE Going Private (Again)
The company behind SUSE Linux Enterprise, Rancher, and NeuVector recently announced that Marcel LUX III SARL (Marcel), its majority shareholder, intends to delist it from the Frankfurt Stock Exchange by way of a merger.