Zack's Kernel News
Panic on OOM Timeout
Michal Hocko posted some patches implementing a "panic on OOM timout" feature. In other words, when the system detected an out-of-memory condition, it would start a timer. If the OOM killer happened to kill the correct process and free up enough memory, then the system would continue running. But, if it couldn't find the right process in the time allotted, there would be a panic, producing some hopefully usable debugging information, and the system could be rebooted in an orderly fashion. Without the timer, Michal argued, the OOM killer could just go on killing the wrong processes, leaving the system unusable for an unpredictable amount of time. The timer, he said, added an important element of predictability to the situation.
Tetsuo Handa, who had worked on a similar feature some months earlier, agreed with the feature in principle but had questions about the implementation. The two immediately launched into a technical comparison of their two patch sets, discussing specific scenarios that could lead to the timeout taking too long and other undesirable end results.
Part of the complexity of the debate arose from the fact that in an out-of-memory situation, the system is already ailing, so the question becomes identifying which ailments are preferable to others, when a given code path is trying too hard to solve a problem that won't make enough of a difference anyway, and whether a given code path gives up and shuts down the system while there is still hope of resurrecting it.
The two went back and forth for a while, each essentially defending their own implementations while also submitting additional patches that might either win the other over or address the other's concerns. Ultimately, their approaches grew closer together, but there was no true resolution by the end of the discussion.
The whole question of how to handle out-of-memory conditions is very thorny. It's possible that a technically superior approach might be rejected by Linus Torvalds or someone else along the way just because of the maintenance burden it would create. To some extent, the proper behavior might depend on the most likely user, which can also be hard to identify.
« Previous 1 2
Buy this article as PDF
(incl. VAT)
Buy Linux Magazine
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
News
-
Canonical Releases Ubuntu 24.04
After a brief pause because of the XZ vulnerability, Ubuntu 24.04 is now available for install.
-
Linux Servers Targeted by Akira Ransomware
A group of bad actors who have already extorted $42 million have their sights set on the Linux platform.
-
TUXEDO Computers Unveils Linux Laptop Featuring AMD Ryzen CPU
This latest release is the first laptop to include the new CPU from Ryzen and Linux preinstalled.
-
XZ Gets the All-Clear
The back door xz vulnerability has been officially reverted for Fedora 40 and versions 38 and 39 were never affected.
-
Canonical Collaborates with Qualcomm on New Venture
This new joint effort is geared toward bringing Ubuntu and Ubuntu Core to Qualcomm-powered devices.
-
Kodi 21.0 Open-Source Entertainment Hub Released
After a year of development, the award-winning Kodi cross-platform, media center software is now available with many new additions and improvements.
-
Linux Usage Increases in Two Key Areas
If market share is your thing, you'll be happy to know that Linux is on the rise in two areas that, if they keep climbing, could have serious meaning for Linux's future.
-
Vulnerability Discovered in xz Libraries
An urgent alert for Fedora 40 has been posted and users should pay attention.
-
Canonical Bumps LTS Support to 12 years
If you're worried that your Ubuntu LTS release won't be supported long enough to last, Canonical has a surprise for you in the form of 12 years of security coverage.
-
Fedora 40 Beta Released Soon
With the official release of Fedora 40 coming in April, it's almost time to download the beta and see what's new.