Tools for reconstructing deleted data

The Sleuth Kit

One of the most powerful tool collections for forensic work is The Sleuth Kit (TSK) [12], which has been under continuous development for several years. The developer, Brian Carrier, also has a graphical front end called Autopsy [13]. However, the latest version 4.4.1 is only available as a Windows package. To use Autopsy with Linux, you must build it from the source code, which poses massive problems because of partly missing, partly incorrectly designated dependencies.

Because TSK is intended as a command-line tool for users who perform professional data analysis and forensic work, the tool collection is also suitable for many tasks beyond the actual reconstruction of data.

The tools can be found in the software repositories of all the major Linux distributions, as well as in many Live systems with a focus on IT security and data maintenance [14]. TSK includes many tools for data analysis and reconstruction; the individual modules collect a variety of information and take metadata, the filesystem, object names, journals, and data blocks into account.

As supported filesystems, the documentation refers to ISO-9660, standard FAT variants, NTFS, ext2/3/4, and the UFS1 and UFS2 filesystems used by several Unix derivatives. Because of the many parameters, TSK requires a longer training period and therefore is less suitable for occasional data recovery. The fls and tsk_recover commands are useful for simple data reconstruction; TSK expects to work on an image generated from the original file as a template, so that it does not destroy reconstructible content by means of accidental write processes on the original disk.

To reconstruct some data on a USB memory stick, first create an image of the damaged drive by using the dd Linux command; the content can then be displayed with the fls <imagefile> command. Files with an asterisk are deleted.

The inode number, which is also listed, then lets you reconstruct a file as follows:

istat <imagefile> <inode_number>


icat <imagefile> <inode_number> > <filename>

tsk_recover also relies on other TSK modules when localizing and recovering deleted data; for example, it recovers all files of an image using the

tsk_recover -e <imagefile> <target_directory>

command sequence. These then end up in subdirectories. The -v option in the command sequence also outputs details to the screen (Figure 8).

Figure 8: TSK modules aid in data reconstruction.


All tested programs are up to the task of reconstructing accidentally deleted data or content from corrupted disks (see also the "Not Included" box). However, the approaches to restoring the data differ significantly: Whereas TSK is suitable for professional forensic applications by providing a variety of parameters, at the other end of the spectrum, Foremost and Magic Rescue are easy to use and provide rapid results.

Not Included

This test did not include the Scalpel [15] file carver. Although it provides functionality similar to Foremost, it only supports a few filesystems, which is not optimal, especially in environments with many different operating systems.

I also did not cover ddrescue [16]. Although the software is very well documented, it was not convincing during a practical test on larger drives with a large amount of lost data and a corrupted partitions table. Because ddrescue scans the disk several times, depending on the severity of the damage, an attempt to reconstruct the data can take several hours for USB memory sticks of just a few gigabytes. It was also impossible to repair disks that exhibited pronounced fragmentation of residual data as a result of overwriting in a reasonable amount of time.

Anyone who needs professional data reconstruction across an intranet might be interested in the commercial R-Studio. Although the software is not as good as TSK when it comes to court-proof documentation of forensic investigations, its ability to restore lost files outshines PhotoRec and TestDisk.

PhotoRec is well suited for occasional use in multiformat databases, because it provides the most extensive format support.

When it comes to finding a suitable solution, you should first determine your needs before choosing one of these programs for data recovery

Buy this article as PDF

Express-Checkout as PDF
Price $2.95
(incl. VAT)

Buy Linux Magazine

Get it on Google Play

US / Canada

Get it on Google Play

UK / Australia

Related content

  • Parted Magic

    It's really annoying when a disk suddenly dies on you or a typo in a command deletes important data. The free Parted Magic Live distro offers help.

  • SystemRescueCd

    If you accidentally delete data or format a disk, good advice can be expensive. Or maybe not: You can undo many data losses with SystemRescueCd.

  • Data Rescue

    Armed with just standard Linux tools, users can recover files, resurrect partitions, and rescue damaged media.

  • Recovering Deleted Files

    Modern filesystems make forensic file recovery much more difficult. Tools like Foremost and Scalpel identify data structures and carve files from a hard disk image.

  • Top 10 Knoppix Rescue Tricks

    The Knoppix Live Linux distro is packed with powerful tools for fixing broken systems. We ask Knoppix creator Klaus Knopper for his favorite Knoppix rescue tricks.

comments powered by Disqus
Subscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters

Support Our Work

Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.

Learn More